Emma Volume 2 Manga Review and Content Guide (Christian Perspective)

In our review of Emma Volume 2 by Kaoru Mori, we will explore the Victorian romance manga from a Christian perspective. We will also provide an Emma Volume 2 content guide.

To visit our overview post on the entire Emma series, click here.

Synopsis of Emma Volume 2 by Kaoru Mori

As Emma and William’s romance deepens, William is determined to win his father’s approval. However, his father has other plans—arranging a marriage between William and Eleanor, a young noblewoman making her debut in high society.

With few allies and immense societal pressure, Emma and William struggle to fight for their love. But when Emma’s world is suddenly turned upside down, their relationship faces even greater challenges.

As tensions rise, William must decide whether to follow his heart or succumb to family expectations. Meanwhile, Emma faces hardships that threaten to separate them forever. With only Hakim and Mrs. Stownar standing by their side, can they find the strength to stay together—or will the barriers of social class prove too much to overcome?

Emma Volume 2 Review *Mild Spoilers Throughout*

Though only the second volume, Emma takes a significant turn, deepening the relationship between Emma and William. Their first date at the Crystal Palace is a charming and wholesome moment, as they genuinely enjoy each other’s company. Unlike many modern romances, their connection develops through conversation, mutual respect, and sincere interest—qualities that today’s dating culture could certainly learn from.

A Date Unlike Modern Romances

Their outing takes an unexpected turn when they lose track of time and end up locked in the Crystal Palace overnight. However, this moment is handled with integrity—William stays awake to ensure Emma’s safety, showcasing a level of respect often missing in many romance stories. Though they share a first kiss, their relationship remains pure and restrained, making this a refreshing departure from more sensationalized romance tropes.

A Love Facing Opposition

This volume also highlights the social barriers Emma and William must navigate. Apart from Mrs. Stownar and Hakim, nearly everyone—especially William’s family—opposes their relationship. The stark contrast between supporters and opponents adds depth to the story, emphasizing the rigid class divisions of Victorian England.

Hakim: An Unexpected Ally

Initially, Hakim seems like an unnecessary side character, but he proves to be one of the strongest advocates for Emma and William. He offers Emma invaluable advice and fights for their love even more than they do, which can be both endearing and frustrating—since Emma and William remain far too passive about their own happiness.

Emma’s Tragic Past: A Story of Survival

We also learn more about Emma’s heartbreaking backstory. She was raised by an abusive aunt and uncle and narrowly escaped being trafficked as a child. Though she avoids the worst, she is left homeless and vulnerable until the kind-hearted Mrs. Stownar takes her in. This element of the story, while brief, highlights a serious real-world issue that still affects many children today.

Emma Manga Review: A Christian Perspective on Class, Respect, and Biblical Themes

Mrs. Stownar cares for Emma like a mother, embodying biblical principles such as James 1:27 and Exodus 22:22. Unlike many in high society, she does not look down on Emma because she is a maid. Instead, Mrs. Stownar treats Emma like a daughter, showing kindness by allowing her to borrow a dress and even offering her an entire day off. Her love and care reflect the biblical call to compassion and respect for others.

William’s Respect for Emma: A Positive Example

Although William made mistakes in the previous volume (such as looking at a risqué magazine), he treats Emma with deep respect. When Emma falls asleep in the Crystal Palace, he does not take advantage of the moment. Instead, he protects her and prioritizes her well-being. They do share a kiss, but it is mutual and handled with care.

The Darker Themes: Human Trafficking in Emma

Emma’s journey is not for the faint of heart. She narrowly escapes being sold into prostitution, highlighting the grim reality of human trafficking. This unsettling topic reflects real-world issues that, while uncomfortable, must be confronted—especially from a Christian perspective. The manga acknowledges that some individuals prey on the vulnerable, a heartbreaking truth that underscores the need to fight for the protection of innocent lives (Psalm 82:3-4).

Biblical Themes of Equality and Social Status

William does not reject Emma because of her lower social class; instead, he sees her as a woman he deeply loves and values, regardless of societal expectations. This reflects biblical truths about equality—God does not let social standing determine a person’s worth. Proverbs 22:2 reminds us, “Rich and poor have this in common: The Lord is the Maker of them all.” Likewise, Galatians 3:28 affirms that in Christ, “there is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.”

However, William struggles with the expectations of his social class, allowing external pressures to keep him from fully committing to Emma. His internal conflict mirrors the real-world challenge of overcoming societal norms to follow one’s convictions.

Mr. Jones: A Contrast in Perspective

Unlike William, Mr. Jones views Emma’s status as a maid as a barrier that should not be crossed. He rejects the idea of her as an equal, believing that William’s love for a servant is both ridiculous and socially unacceptable. His attitude reflects the rigid class divisions of Victorian England, contrasting sharply with William’s more open-minded approach.

---

Emma Volume 2 FAQs

---

Conclusion: Emma Volume 2 Manga Review

The Emma manga presents a compelling exploration of love, respect, and social class through a Christian perspective. It challenges readers to consider how faith, equality, and compassion should influence our views on relationships and social status. With themes of biblical love, kindness, and justice, Emma serves as a meaningful story that resonates with Christian values.

To read our review of Emma Volume 3, click here.

---

Content Guide for Emma Volume 2

Language & Insults in Emma Volume 2

• For God’s sake
• What the devil
• Blimey
• Drat
• Codswallop
• Crikey
• Grotty
• Hell to pay
• Hussy
• Thag you
• Whelp
• Brat
• Simpleton
• Fool
• Country bumpkin
• Urchins
• Daft

Nudity & Sexuality in Emma Volume 2

• A maid undresses Eleanor, showing her in a nightgown with cleavage.
• A girl in a corset shows slight cleavage.
• A prostitute with cleavage appears in a kidnapping scene, which includes attempting to sell minors for horrific acts.
• Hakim lounges with women in traditional crop tops, showing backs but no cleavage.
• The author describes her process at the end of the book and draws herself in a cartoonish nude character, but there are no anatomical details to speak of–she resembles a box with a head and arms/legs.

Violence & Gore in Emma Volume 2

• Emma is kidnapped, thrown into a wagon, and nearly trafficked before escaping.

• Emma was physically, verbally, and emotionally abused by her aunt and uncle.

Alcohol/Drugs/Smoking in Emma Volume 2

Alcohol/Smoking: Drinking at dinner; William recalls a drinking mishap. Ladies mention men likely want to smoke after dinner. A neighbor smokes a pipe.

Religion in Emma Volume 2

• Mentions “May God bless you.”

Emma Volume 2 by Kaoru Mori manga cover. From Amazon. Under fair use for review/commentary/criticism. All rights retained by respective owners.